Categories
Uncategorized

Coffee Bean That Melts Fat?

That was the subject line of an email in my Inbox this morning. I almost deleted it straight away because it was SPAM from some company I’d never asked to send me stuff, but I thought no, let’s have a look. So I opened it up and was greeted by a scantily clad, skinny lady – rather like the one on the cover of my book How to Lose Weight Easily – and emblazoned across her very attractive bosom in giant writing were the words.

Weight Loss Experts
CAN’T BELIEVE THIS

I couldn’t believe it.

They were absolutely right.

I am a weight loss expert and I can’t believe it.

Having come this far, I thought I’d better check this out, after all it might make for something interesting to write about today. My intention being to quickly discover that it was a load of rubbish and then tell you why and what was wrong with the research.

You might think it’s quite easy to track down a piece of research these days with the internet being what it is. But, truth be told, Google is a bit rubbish when you want to find out specific and accurate information. What tends to happen is that you trawl through twenty, thirty, forty promising looking sites only to find out that they are all rehashing the same information which originated in the same press release. Occasionally there is a snippet of fresh information that leads, like a trail of breadcrumbs either to the goal, or to a giving up on the search.

It really is important to locate the original research paper because, quite often, distortions creep into the reporting of what the results mean. Especially when the reporting is done by a company whose product sales are going to benefit.

For instance one site reported

“16 overweight young adults”

Another…

“The 16 people were obese or overweight and between the age of 22 and 26.”

The study actually used 16 people between the ages of 22 and 46.

The key author of the study is cited as Dr Joe A Vinson, a chemist at the University of Scranton, PA, but the study was conducted in Bangalore, India. Dr Vinson’s research was funded by Applied Food Sciences. Applied Food Sciences are the company that supplied the Green Coffee Bean Extract (GCA – Green Coffee Antioxidant) that the research was testing!!!!

Looking at Dr Vinson’s list of publications on the University website it seems he is a leading light in researching natural products that produce health benefits. But I am nevertheless suspicious when the guy who is paying the bills is also the guy whose products you are testing to see if they do what they say.

Back to the research: 16 people is such a small sample that no statistically significant conclusions can be drawn – which makes me wonder why bother. That said, the results are certainly interesting. The study ran for 22 weeks. Participants had a period with a low dose green coffee extract, a period with a higher dose, and a period with a placebo. There was a two week recovery period between each test. Over that time the subjects showed an average weight loss of 18lbs. 10 subjects had 10% loss of body weight, and 5 of the other 6 lost 5% of their body weight. Average heart rate slowed by 2 beats a minute – this doesn’t sound much but is significant for heart health. There are also indications, but nothing statistically significant, that there might be beneficial effects on blood pressure.

It is important to note here that Green Coffee Extract is low in caffeine. The caffeine comes when the beans are roasted. The extract used is primarily chlorogenic acid which is removed from the green beans, but is destroyed in the roasting process so drinking more coffee isn’t going to do you any good.

You’ll find elsewhere on this site my comments about two drugs, Belviq and Qsymia that the FDA recently approved for use with weight loss – both of which look like they could have very serious long-term side effects. A 22 week trial isn’t going to identify long-term side effects, but no short-term side effects were reported in this coffee bean trial.

It looks to me as though this trial was created specifically to provide scientific evidence and backing to promote the sale of Applied Food Science’s GCA. It is too small to be of any use for anything other than to provide quotable results from a clinical trial in order to convince customers of the product’s efficacy. However, the results are interesting, so I cannot say, as I was hoping to, that this is just more junk. If you are desperate for a solution in a pill – this might help you. If you decide to take it then please let me know how you get on.

Michael

 

If you want to check it out yourself you can find the report here:

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3267522/?tool=pubmed

Categories
Uncategorized

Qsymia/Qnexa – the New Weight Loss Miracle Drug.

I don’t have a lot of time for pharmaceuticals – especially for those associated with weight loss, but there’s a new one, Qnexa (which will be marketed under the brand name Qsymia), that’s about to receive FDA approval. So I thought I’d do a little bit of research and find out what all the fuss is about.

Here’s what I found out. Qnexa is manufactured by Vivus Inc. On the day the FDA panel voted 20 to 2 in favour of approval, Vivus’ stock jumped 98%.

So that’s great isn’t it?

FDA approval means it’s safe and it does what it claims it will do – doesn’t it?

And that’s got to be really good news for people struggling to lose weight – hasn’t it?

Well…

One of the things most people don’t know about pharmaceutical solutions is that all drugs have side effects. What approval means is that the benefits outweigh the side effects. Sometimes drug side effects are quite severe, but if the drug means the difference between life and death then the severe side effects can be tolerated. If it’s an over the counter preparation (OTC) available without prescription then the side effect tolerance is much lower – in theory at least. You might want to check this out for more on OTC safety

So how does this new drug work and will it really help you to lose weight?

Qnexa is a mixture of phentermine and topiramate.

Phentermine

Phentermine was a part of a diet drug marketed in the 1980’s but it was withdrawn because it damaged heart valves. It works like amphetamines and suppresses appetite. It has two sigificant side effects – tachycardia and elevated blood pressure. Interestingly, the FDA is concerned about heart risk with phentermine and is looking at the possibility of further studies – but these will only be required after approval and not before. Safety seems to me to be taking a back seat when there are billions of dollars waiting to be made.

Interestingly the appetite suppressant effect of phentermine only lasts a few weeks, so the problem will be to stop people increasing the dosage when this happens. Especially if they have enjoyed watching the pounds fall away effortlessly.

Increased dosage means increased risk.

But let’s not ignore the other drug that contributes to the magic of Qnexa – topiramate.

Topiramate

Here are some of the listed side effects:

Depression, confusion, chest pain, memory loss, difficulty breathing, concentration problems, hallucinations, difficulty with speech, fainting, mood swings, paranoia, fatigue, vision difficulty and eye pain, wanting to sleep, deep vein thrombosis, suicide, hyperglycemia, kidney stones, and allergic reactions.

42% of people taking this drug reported cognitive or mental problems.

Qnexa itself seems to be causing serious concerns relating to cardiovascular problems (just as with most other miracle weight loss drugs that had to be withdrawn) and also possible birth defects (cleft lip & cleft palate). The solution to this, suggested by the manufacturers, is adequate birth control!!!!

So it’s looking good so far.

But when we look a little deeper into this we begin to see something more than a wonder drug that benefactors Vivus are blessing humanity with.

FDA – going through the motions

Before the vote the FDA prepared a 161 page document espousing Qnexa’s benefits and strongly recommending approval. The FDA, by the way, gets most of it’s funding from the pharmaceutical industry. Isn’t that a bit like letting the criminal fraternity run the Justice System? It seems that wisdom, and the safety of those tha FDA is supposed to be protecting (the American people), fall by the wayside in the FDA’s desperate attempt to come up with an ‘easy solution’ to the obesity epidemic that the US is suffering from. And, of course, the medical mindset is that the only solution is a pharmacological one. Never mind encouraging people to do something simple and safe like eating a little less and exercising a little more.

The problem, it seems, is that there is no competition for this new drug, so everyone who wants to carry on eating and make no changes to their lifestyle sees this as an easy option. Every one will want it. Everyone wants the easy option. Even though a prescription will be required it will be available without through internet sources and Vivus will make billions of dollars.

“This drug, if approved, would likely be prescribed to millions or tens of millions of people,” said Dr. Michael Lauer, director of the division of cardiovascular sciences at the National Institutes of Health. Dr Lauer voted against the approval of this drug back in 2010, and was one of the two who voted against recently. He also says “We cannot assume that just because a drug reduces weight and improves some biomarkers that it will be safe, let alone beneficial.”

Serious Safety Concerns

The overwhelming consensus (outside of the FDA of course) is that there are potentially serious cardiovascular problems with this drug and it needs much more rigorous examination. That examination needs to take place prior to approval, not after. But the writing is on the wall and the desperate search for a magical solution to a lifestyle problem is going to ensure that profits win out over safety and the only ones who will suffer are those who trust their doctors and are desperate for help with a problem they feel powerless to impact.

 

Michael

My thanks to:
http://www.justiceforyou.com/2012/02/consequences-qnexa-side-effects-american-consumer/
http://www.forbes.com/sites/melaniehaiken/2012/02/23/new-diet-drug-qnexa-promises-10-weight-loss-at-what-price/
http://marilynmann.wordpress.com/tag/michael-lauer/
http://www.theheart.org/article/1361583.do